
It is deeply troubling when a season traditionally associated with solidarity, sharing, tolerance and togetherness is turned into an instrument of political confrontation. More troubling still is the use of public schools to feed narratives that pit communities against one another.
Chega has revived the claim that Portuguese schools are canceling Christmas celebrations because they are attended by children from immigrant families, particularly Muslim families. The claim is familiar, and the facts provide little ground for the credence its proponents would have us give it.
Fact-checkers have already examined these allegations, and several school administrations have denied banning or canceling Christmas celebrations. At Gil Vicente Secondary School in Lisbon, the administration clarified that it had never banned a Christmas party and confirmed that the school had put up decorations and held activities marking the season. In Pinhal Novo, a dispute over the use of neutral backdrops in school photographs was portrayed as the cancellation of Christmas. Christmas activities went ahead.
So when Chega is pressed to name the schools where these celebrations were supposedly banned, where are the examples? Where are the decisions by school administrators, the directives from the Ministry of Education, or the documents that substantiate these allegations? A claim gains no truth from being repeated, shared on social media or turned into a political speech.
Disinformation often works this way. Take an incident out of context, give it a convenient interpretation, link it to a group of people and repeat it until suspicion takes on the appearance of fact. By then, the corrections rarely reach as many people.
It is a serious matter when immigration is made the stock explanation for anything that can be cast as a threat to national identity. As though the presence of children from different cultural or religious backgrounds placed our traditions in peril. As though respecting diversity meant surrendering our own culture. As though we could not celebrate Christmas and respect those who do not.
Public schools should be places where children learn, live alongside one another, feel included and come to respect differences. Celebrating Christmas requires no profession of faith, just as respecting other beliefs requires no erasure of tradition. The two can readily coexist, especially where children and their education are concerned.
Portuguese culture is sustained by knowing our history, keeping traditions alive, passing on our values and teaching new generations that respect for others also shapes who we are. Inventing threats and looking for someone to blame among those who arrive in our country serves none of that work.
Christmas needs no defense against immigrant children. It needs protection from political exploitation, intolerance and lies. There is a fundamental difference between defending traditions and manufacturing enemies. And when politicians need a threat to rally people, perhaps we ought to look more closely at the story they have woven around schools, children and immigration.
Truth is indispensable to political debate.
Has any school in the Azores canceled its Christmas activities? That question is already overdue for an answer from the authorities responsible.
Alexandra Manes is from Flores Island but lives on Terceira Island in the Azores. She is a regular contributor to several Azorean newspapers, a political and cultural activist, and has served in the Azorean Parliament.
NOVIDADES will feature occasional opinion pieces from leading thinkers and writers in the Azores, providing the diaspora and those interested in the current state of the Azores with a sense of the significant perspectives on some of the archipelago’s issues.
Translated to English as a community outreach program from the Portuguese Beyond Borders Institute (PBBI)
