Trifles & Tangles

The conditions for a steady, predictable tourism industry have deteriorated badly.

We are still embroiled in contractual disputes with airlines that fly, or once flew, to the Azores, under the illusion that we can take them on over trifles worth millions to us and pennies to them. Such was the case with Ryanair, an affair still awaiting the transparent explanation voters are entitled to expect. Obstinacy comes at a price, and taking on giants, by Azorean standards, costs dearer still.

Ours is a system of self-government built around personalities, where every political pawn has a grand and hollow sense of its own importance.

For some of the figures in this coalition of republicans and monarchists (?), the sole point of agreement is a shared interest in being in government. By which I mean Power. It is a fragile government, obliged to bring former party leaders into its own ranks to hold itself together. Their merits, after all, have always been in question.

At fifty, this democracy might have learned better political manners if its interests were more collective and less partisan. That much is plain in the debates we get to watch. The deputies are on better behavior when they know they are being filmed for the delight of a public that increasingly pays them no heed. Insults, tavern brawls, scarcely a shred of dignity. All that’s missing are a few plates to throw at one another. They don’t speak! They shout. They bellow, as though the sheer din could lend weight to an argument. They forget whom they represent.

Mind you, the same spectacle can be seen in the national parliament at São Bento.

The people are growing weary of this dysfunctional system. What passes for democratic debate looks more like women squabbling in the street or men trading slaps in a tavern over jealousies, grudges and loves gone awry or betrayed.

To represent the people, to make politics one’s work and profession, is to remember on whose behalf we occupy those seats. We sit there for those who voted for us, who believed in us, in our character and our abilities, and who entrusted us with defending their rights and working for the advancement of all. Politics is a dignified calling and ought to be practiced with Dignity.

And why do we see what we see?

Because no deputy is answerable to anyone. Each was elected because someone put their name on a party list that voters had to accept as a whole. The important thing is to fill the lists. The quality of the candidates counts for little.

Under a system of single-member constituencies, or something along those lines, each deputy would be elected by the constituency they represented. They would answer to the voters of that constituency, which might be a municipality, for example.

The Azores have nineteen municipalities. Give each of them two representatives in the regional assembly and we would have thirty-eight deputies. A reasonable number, compared with the fifty-seven we have now, which is simply too many.

Under the current system, those fifty-seven deputies are elected to four-year terms by universal, direct and secret suffrage. Direct is precisely what it isn’t. We are presented with party lists and asked to vote for people we don’t know. We vote for parties. Who fills those lists, and with whom, is anybody’s guess. What governs the choice is the interest of each party. A single-member constituency system would be open to any citizen who wished to stand. The present system admits only those the parties choose, often for reasons kept out of sight when it comes to who makes the list and who is left off.

Tourism in the Azores is turning into one hell of a mess. The more players crowd around it, the worse it gets. They soak up millions of euros and have little to show for it. Business owners are giving up. Short-term rentals have become an economic and financial nightmare. Hundreds of businesses that depend directly or indirectly on the sector are shutting their doors.

The outlook is cloudy, with an orange warning in effect.

José Soares is a journalist and contibuting writer for several newspapers in the Azores and the diaspora.